Lessons on the right to assembly
Why in News
On October 12, 2026, the Delhi Police denotified Jantar Mantar as a designated venue for protests and demonstrations, replacing one of the capital's longest-established sites of public dissent with three alternative grounds farther from the seat of power. The move came amid large-scale protests in Delhi against the Central government over the large-scale exclusion of voters in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR), with protesters demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The government responded with a heavy hand, deploying police and military personnel. The article examines how this offends the constitutional rights to expression and assembly.
What is the issue
- The article argues that the right to dissent and protest is integral to any liberal democracy, with a rich legacy in India.
- That legacy is traceable to the independence movement and to agitations by trade unions, farmers and social activists.
- It identifies an emerging 'culture of suspicion' — popular among the right-wing — that distrusts any disagreement with the government.
- This culture treats questions of 'permission' for protests or 'funding' of protesters as central, refusing to see citizens as autonomous agents.
- The constitutional framework invoked is Right to Assembly under Article 19(1)(b), alongside free speech and expression.
- Restrictions are permissible only under Article 19(3) — Reasonable Restrictions, in the interests of sovereignty and integrity or public order.
- The author points to a gap between the liberal state's constitutional spirit and an executive that constrains this right.
- The constraints include disproportionate invocation of preventive laws, disproportionate force on peaceful protesters, and long detentions without disclosing whereabouts.
- The author's core argument is that the heart of the constitutional right to protest lies in not treating protesters with suspicion.
- Public places must be easily accessible if any meaningful right to assembly is to exist, which is why the denotification of Jantar Mantar as a Protest Site assumes serious relevance.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers: