The SIR Verdict: Serious Constitutional Questions on Electoral Rolls and Citizenship
UPSCEditorialsSource: Opinions | The Hindu
1
Why in News
- The Supreme Court of India delivered a verdict on May 27, 2026, upholding the Election Commission of India's power to conduct a 'limited' inquiry into citizenship under the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
- The verdict was challenged against the ECI's notification dated June 24, 2025, which ordered a fresh SIR beginning with Bihar, superseding the Special Summary Revision published on January 6, 2025.
- The author, Senior Advocate Bishwajit Bhattacharyya, argues the Court erred in giving the ECI unguided discretion to delete names on suspicion of citizenship.
- The SIR is now being implemented in other States amid protests, after mass deletions and surprising inclusions in Bihar and West Bengal.
2
What is the issue
- The core question is whether the Supreme Court erred in empowering the Election Commission of India to conduct a 'limited' inquiry into citizenship for inclusion or exclusion of names in electoral rolls.
- A second question raised is whether crystallised electoral rolls can be unsettled in later elections by deleting names merely on suspicion.
- The ECI's June 24, 2025 SIR effectively called into question every electoral roll in Bihar between January 1, 2003 (last SIR) and January 6, 2025 (last SSR), and thus every election held in that period.
- The author contends this was unnecessary since the ECI already periodically updates rolls efficiently, and the exercise entailed mass deletions and surprising inclusions.
- The Court held the ECI's power affects an individual's entitlement to be included in the roll but does not divest citizenship claims or foreclose determination under the Citizenship Act.
- The author argues the words 'limited' and 'strict sense' carry no legal significance, and the ECI's role should be strictly ministerial — ensuring only adulthood and Indian citizenship.
- The article invokes Article 326 (qualifications and disqualifications), natural justice, and the basic structure doctrine on free and fair elections.
- It matters because a citizen already on the roll as of January 6, 2025 could be disenfranchised from July 1, 2025 without a pre-decisional hearing.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:
What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS