Concerns over the Collegium System
UPSCPolitySource: The Hindu – National
1
Why in News
- Retired Supreme Court judge Justice Sanjay Kaul said former CJI D.Y. Chandrachud may have discussed proposed judgeship names with the Union Government before the collegium met.
- He characterised this as seeking the government's 'pre-approval', which in his view erodes the judiciary's autonomy.
- The remarks revive a long-running debate on how judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts are appointed in India.
- The article, by former IAS officer Rangarajan R., situates the controversy within the constitutional provisions and the collegium system devised by the Supreme Court.
2
What is the issue
- Constitutional basis: Article 124 provides that Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consulting the CJI; Article 217 covers High Court judges.
- Original design: the original Constitution provided for consultation by the executive with the judiciary to safeguard judicial independence and ensure quality of appointments.
- Executive primacy phase: till the 1980s judges were appointed by the government after consultation with the judiciary.
- First Judges case (1981): the Supreme Court upheld the primacy of the executive in judicial appointments since it is accountable to the people.
- Collegium created: in the Second Judges case (1993), citing the need to insulate the judiciary from political favouritism, the Court created the collegium system.
- Reaffirmation: the Supreme Court's opinion in the Third Judges case (1998) reaffirmed the collegium.
- The core tension: the executive's role in consultation versus the judiciary's claim to autonomy, with the alleged 'pre-approval' practice as the latest flashpoint.
- Stakeholders: the Supreme Court collegium, the Union Government and Law Ministry, the judiciary's credibility, and litigants who depend on an independent bench.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:
What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsBackgroundKey Important PointsPrelims RelatedMains RelatedImportant WordsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS