Start free
← Back to Current Affairs
Current Affairs · 7 November 2026

Supreme Court Reaffirms Creamy Layer Ruling for OBCs, Rejects Centre's Plea for Two-Year Deferment

UPSCPolitySource: Indian Express – Legal News
1

Why in News

  • The Supreme Court on Friday reaffirmed its March 11 judgment holding that creamy layer status of OBCs cannot be decided solely on parental income.
  • The Centre had sought clarifications and directions on applying the judgment to OBC candidates selected in the Civil Services Examination.
  • A bench of Justices P S Narasimha and R Mahadevan disposed of the Centre's plea, finding no convincing justification for deferring implementation.
  • The Centre had asked for a two-year period to establish equivalence of posts and urged that the judgment not apply retrospectively.
  • The court extended by eight weeks the six-month deadline it had earlier given the Centre for implementation.
2

What is the issue

  • The dispute traces to a DoPT letter of October 14, 2004, clarifying a September 1993 Official Memorandum on the creamy layer criterion for OBCs.
  • The 1993 OM excluded income from salary and agricultural sources from the income/wealth test for creamy layer status.
  • The 2004 clarification made salary income of employees in PSUs and the private sector a criterion for determining creamy layer status.
  • This clarification was not implemented effectively until 2014 and was applied rigorously from CSE-2015 (the 2016 batch).
  • Since then, around 100 OBC candidates who cleared the CSE have had their claims rejected by the DoPT on creamy layer grounds.
  • The Central Administrative Tribunal and the High Courts of Madras, Delhi and Kerala ruled in the candidates' favour.
  • The March 11 judgment came on the Centre's petition challenging those High Court decisions granting relief.
  • The Centre argued the judgment should not reopen completed selections, appointments, service allocations, cadre allocations, seniority or admissions.
  • The core tension is between the binding precedent under Article 141 and the relief being confined to parties before the court, protecting settled service administration.
Detailed analysis

The full analysis is in the app

This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:

What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsBackgroundKey Important PointsPrelims RelatedMains RelatedImportant WordsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS