Kerala Lawyer Seeks Amendment to Muslim Inheritance Law for Orphaned Grandchildren
UPSCPolitySource: Indian Express – Legal News
1
Why in News
- Siraj Karoly, a senior lawyer in the Kerala High Court, has asked the Law Commission to recommend an amendment to the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937.
- The plea seeks to introduce an Obligatory Bequest (Wasiyyat Wajibah) under which children of a predeceased son or daughter receive their parent’s share, up to one-third of the total estate.
- The trigger is the ordinary operation of classical Sunni inheritance law, under which orphaned grandchildren are excluded by nearer heirs such as uncles.
- The representation was made earlier this month, putting the question of reform of Muslim personal law before the Law Commission.
2
What is the issue
- Classical Sunni law excludes the remote heir by nearer ones: children of a deceased son are shut out by his surviving brother, and children of a deceased daughter fare even worse.
- Shia, Hindu and Christian orphaned grandchildren succeed by the doctrine of representation, creating a disparity between communities under one Constitution.
- The remedy requires no rewriting of Islamic law: a bequest to a non-heir up to one-third of the net estate is valid under the Hanafi school.
- Ibn Hazm, the Zahiri School jurist, held that a bequest of up to one-third to orphan grandchildren is a duty a judge may enforce; Egypt’s law of 1946 was codified on this line.
- For Shia Muslims, whose law already gives the grandchild the parent’s share, the bequest merely confirms an existing right.
- The issue engages Articles 14, 15, 21 and 25(2)(b) of the Constitution, and the weakening of Narasu Appa Mali after Shayara Bano.
- Stakeholders include the AIMPLB, the Law Commission, Parliament, and Sunni and Shia communities; the model must treat sons’ and daughters’ children alike.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:
What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsBackgroundKey Important PointsPrelims RelatedMains RelatedImportant WordsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS