At COP31, look beyond the biggest emitters: lifestyle responsibility and climate justice
UPSCEditorialsSource: Indian Express – Opinion
1
Why in News
- Policymakers gather this week in Antalya, Turkey for COP31, the UN climate conference meant to implement solutions to slow warming, limit overshoot of 1.5 degree C and help countries adapt.
- A new peer-reviewed framework asks who is responsible for warming by imagining that all humanity had historically lived like the people of a given country, and finds that small, super-affluent countries have lifestyles that would be even more destabilising than those of the US and Europe.
- Nepal's Prime Minister Balendra Shah, speaking at the UN General Assembly in September after a "Himalayan tsunami" killed nearly 1,500 people (with over 5,000 missing), said communities are "hit by the climate we did not warm and by the wars we did not start".
2
What is the issue
- The common view holds that the US and Europe bear the greatest responsibility for climate action, but this misses the full picture of who is driving warming through lifestyles.
- The thought experiment: if all humanity had historically lived a given country's lifestyle, how much warming would there have been by now? Actual warming by 2022 was about 1.3 degree C.
- Had the world lived like the average British citizen, warming would be about 2.5 degree C, and like the average American, about 3.7 degree C. For small, super-affluent countries the figures are higher still: Singapore about 2 degree C, Luxembourg nearly 4 degree C, and Qatar over 5 degree C.
- By contrast, the historical lifestyles of the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) would have caused only 0.6 degree C, and India about 0.8 degree C.
- So global inequality has inadvertently subsidised climate stability: affluent countries avoided climate collapse only because most people did not live as they do.
- For developing countries the injustice is double: they bear the brunt of disasters they did not cause, and their low emissions have bought the world valuable time.
- Responsibility for climate solutions therefore rests on small super-affluent countries too, not only on large rich ones.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:
What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsBackgroundKey Important PointsPrelims RelatedMains RelatedImportant WordsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS