World Bank's 2.6 per cent extreme poverty estimate for India and the thali test
UPSCEditorialsSource: Indian Express – Opinion
1
Why in News
- The World Bank recently released estimates pegging extreme poverty in India at 2.6 per cent, which would suggest that high levels of economic deprivation are a thing of the past.
- A "thali index" analysis of the same Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) 2023-24 shows that about 30 per cent of Indians cannot afford two square meals a day, making the sub-3 per cent estimate hard to accept.
- With food price inflation rising every month between January and September (trebling over the period), the analysis calls for an urgent review of policies to control food prices.
2
What is the issue
- The World Bank's figure is a headcount ratio: the number of poor divided by the population, found by applying a poverty line to the NSS Household Consumption Expenditure Survey 2023-24. The basket of goods and prices behind the line for India is not spelt out.
- The thali index measures how many thalis a person can buy from monthly per capita food expenditure reported in the HCES; a thali is a culturally familiar, nutritious unit of a complete meal. The price used is Rs 30, the cost of a home-cooked vegetarian thali in 2023-24, the cheapest option.
- On this measure, up to 50 per cent of rural and 20 per cent of urban Indians cannot afford two thalis a day. After adding the value of subsidised food, the shares fall to 40 per cent and 10 per cent, or about 30 per cent of the population overall.
- Both estimates use the same survey; the difference is that the Bank uses an income-based poverty line while the thali index uses directly observed food consumption.
- Even if the poverty line income could buy two thalis, households must first pay for rent, medicines and school fees, so food becomes a residual item; the line must reflect a minimum food consumption criterion.
- The same logic applies to the UNDP's Multidimensional Poverty Index, to the extent that it relies on the Bank's poverty line.
- A very low estimate can create complacency in policy: if poverty is almost non-existent, there is little urgency to act.
The full analysis is in the app
This page is the summary. The detailed analysis of this story covers:
What is the statusWhat are the challengesWhat measuresWhat lies aheadImportant Data PointsBackgroundKey Important PointsPrelims RelatedMains RelatedImportant WordsKey conceptsPrevious year questions
Open in Quorum IAS