Start free
← Back to Study Material
Study material · UPSC

Indian Economy: Introduction

Chapter 1 of Indian Economy, complete and free to read.

1.1Introduction to Economics and Economy

What Economics Studies

Economics is the study of how goods and services are produced, distributed and consumed. Resources are always in short supply. So the British economist Lionel Robbins, in 1935, described economics as the science of scarcity.

Development economics is a separate school of economics. It arose when decolonisation began and developing countries with mass poverty needed to develop. It is dedicated to the cause and cure of mass poverty. It keeps the earlier focus on efficient allocation of resources but from a perspective that stresses eradicating poverty. It brings together the best of all schools of economics and consolidates them.

  • Development economics marries efficiency to effectiveness. Efficiency means output for input; effectiveness means achieving overall results.
  • Development economics is mainly centred on why poverty persists despite extensive economic growth, and on ways to eradicate it.
  • Economics first dealt with efficient allocation of resources for maximum growth. Later it balanced growth with redistribution, and so a welfare focus emerged.
  • Development economics undertakes studies to understand poverty so that it can be effectively alleviated.
  • Development economics keeps the earlier focus on efficient allocation of resources, but from a perspective that stresses eradicating poverty.

Development economics is a distinct school of economics. It came up when decolonisation began and developing countries with mass poverty needed to develop. It is dedicated to the cause and cure of mass poverty.

  • Development economics keeps the earlier focus on efficient allocation of resources, but from a perspective that stresses eradicating poverty.
  • It brings together the best of all schools of economics and consolidates them.
  • It marries efficiency to effectiveness: efficiency is output for input, effectiveness is achieving overall results.
  • It is mainly centred on why poverty persists despite extensive economic growth, and on ways to eradicate it.
  • It undertakes studies to understand poverty so that it can be effectively alleviated.
  • Economics first dealt with efficient allocation of resources for maximum growth. Later it balanced growth with redistribution, and so a welfare focus emerged.

Economics: The Discipline

Every discipline begins by defining itself. But giving one complete definition is never easy. Different economists see the subject from different angles and give different definitions. Many of these definitions became narrow or hard to understand. Still, a working definition is needed to study the subject.

Two widely accepted definitions are given below.

  • Economics is the study of how societies use scarce resources to produce valuable commodities and distribute them among different people. Two key ideas stand out: goods are scarce, and society must use its resources efficiently. Scarcity and the need for efficient use make economics important.
  • Economics studies how individuals, firms, governments and other organisations in society make choices, and how these choices decide a society's use of its resources.

Human life depends on consuming materials made from the resources available on earth. Human wants have no limit, so we would need infinite resources to satisfy them. But resources are limited. So individuals and society must make choices and set priorities among competing needs. Some needs may never be fulfilled, while some may be fulfilled again and again.

Economics is the discipline that studies how individuals, society and government make prioritised choices in using scarce resources to satisfy the needs and wants of life. Making such choices is both an art and a science. Choices change with time and space, and human needs change too. The discipline of economics grew out of the study of these choices made by humanity in different times and places. Since economics deals with living human beings in the space-time continuum, it is a very dynamic subject and should be read in that spirit.

Over the last half century, economics has covered such varied topics that it serves different purposes for different students. Some study it to make money. This is largely true in the developed world, but not in the developing world, where economics has mostly been read and taught rather than applied. Others study it to learn about poverty, unemployment, human development, shares and debentures, banking norms, prices and their movements, and e-commerce. Still others study it to increase their knowledge of economics.

  • Animal spirit: British economist John Maynard Keynes, in The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, argued that investors and consumers are guided by animal spirit, a psychological urge, more than by unbiased and rational analysis of facts.
  • When animal spirit is more active, people invest and spend more.
  • In 2019 the RBI report observed that despite government efforts, domestic demand was not rising, so animal spirit was not reviving, hence a slowdown in the economy.
  • Pent up demand: during a recession or slowdown people postpone their shopping plans. Once the economy recovers, or in a festival season, there is a sudden rise in shopping. This is called pent up demand.

A Working Definition

To really feel a subject, one should start with its definition. But definitions often become abstract, full of jargon and technical. Such a definition may not give a proper feel of the subject to a person outside economics. Most students of economics also find it hard to grasp the full meaning. That is why a general, layman's definition is needed.

Human beings do many activities in their daily lives. These activities fall into different categories. Economics studies the economic activities of mankind. In the same way, political, social and administrative activities are studied under Political Science, Sociology and Public Administration. All these disciplines are broadly called humanities because they study human activities. Many more specialised human activities are studied under many more disciplines.

Which activities are economic activities? Activities that involve profit, loss, livelihood, occupation, wage and employment are economic activities. Economics studies all of them. Today economics has many branches and studies very diverse subjects at the global, macro and micro levels.

Many questions fall within economics. Why do some people buy fuel-efficient cars while others buy fuel-guzzling sports cars? Why are the poor poor? Is capitalism doomed to deepen economic inequality? Will globalisation bridge the poor-rich divide and have a universal homogenising effect on the world? These days information technology is also giving a new dimension to economics.

Important Person: Lionel Robbins (1935)
  • British economist.
  • Described economics as the science of scarcity.
  • His definition highlights that resources are always in short supply.

Economics and the Economy

The relation between economics and the economy is like the relation between theory and practice. Economics is the discipline that studies the economic behaviour of human beings. The economy is a still-frame picture of that behaviour. Economics gives theories of markets, employment and so on. An economy is the real picture that emerges when those theories are applied.

The economy is economics at play in a certain region. Today this region is best defined as a country or nation, such as the Indian Economy, the Russian Economy or the French Economy. The word economy by itself means nothing. It gets meaning when it is preceded by the name of a country, region or block. Developed economies means the economies of developed countries.

Countries may face some common economic challenges and some very specific ones. Over time, economists have suggested a fixed number of theories and methods to solve these challenges. Each country chooses which set of principles and theories to use. Countries that choose the same remedy for the same problem may get similar or different results in a given period. Two economies that choose different tools for the same problem may also get the same or completely different results.

Why does this happen? Economic theories are expectations about human behaviour in economic activities. Human behaviour depends greatly on many internal and external factors, so results differ. The factors that affect an economy are: the level and quality of natural resources, the quantity and quality of human resources, the socio-political milieu, the historical background, and the psychic make of the human resource. These factors act individually and together. So it is very hard for economists to forecast the impact of a particular policy on a particular economic setting.

Implementation and delivery systems also play a vital role in solving economic challenges. Economists began studying these after the 1960s. So economics has less diversity than economies do. No two economies of the world are exactly the same, though we can group them into broad categories such as developed and developing, or agrarian and industrial.

This diversity makes economics interesting. Through the diverse facts of economies, economists have modified and re-modified their ideas. The evolutionary history of economics is nothing but changes in past theories based on the current results and experiences of economies. Economics has developed out of real-life practice, especially from the evolution of practice into theory. As practice gains new dimensions, economic theories will also gain newer and more imaginative dimensions.

The Focus of Economics

What is the real purpose of studying economics? What have economists been trying to say? What has been the focus of economics since the birth of the discipline?

Economics today studies a wide range of issues. But its essence is simple: the betterment of human life on earth. Improving the living conditions of humanity is the real and ultimate goal of the discipline. Economists have proposed many theories on how an economy can maximise its economic potential and worth.

The first and most famous work in this direction was The Wealth of Nations (1776) by the Scottish philosopher-economist Adam Smith. The classical school of economics traces its origin to this work. In later years and centuries, many great economists produced outstanding works trying to find better ways of maximising the fruits of economic activity. Economics and economists share one common goal: searching for possible alternatives for the betterment of human life.

Important Person: Adam Smith (1723-1790)
  • Scottish philosopher-economist and professor at the University of Glasgow.
  • His writings formed the basis of classical economics.
  • Wrote The Wealth of Nations (1776), the first and most famous work on maximising an economy's potential.
  • Stressed division of labour and laissez faire (non-interference by government).
  • Said the invisible hand of market forces (price mechanism) brings equilibrium and general well-being; he accepted the need for competition in the market.
  • The Harrod-Domar Model explains how economic growth depends on savings and investment. It was developed in the late 1930s and 1940s by Roy F. Harrod and Evsey Domar.
  • It was one of the earliest attempts to explain mathematically how economies grow over time.
  • It became especially influential in development economics, particularly for growth strategies of developing countries.
  • It influenced development planning and was used in the Five-Year Plans.

The Harrod-Domar Model explains how a country's economic growth depends on its savings and investment levels. It was developed in the late 1930s and 1940s by Roy F. Harrod and Evsey Domar. It was one of the earliest attempts to explain mathematically how economies grow over time. It became especially influential in development economics, particularly for understanding growth strategies of developing countries. It influenced development planning and was used in the Five-Year Plans.

Challenges of the Economies

The main challenge of any economy is to fulfil the needs of its population. Every population needs goods and services for survival and well-being. Goods include basic needs such as food, shelter and garments, and also refrigerators, air conditioners, cars, medicines and computers. Services range from healthcare, drinking water supply and education to advanced services like banking, insurance, airways, telephones and internet.

As an economy moves up the ladder of development, fulfilling the needs of the population becomes a never-ending process. When one set of goods and services is supplied, the population demands another set of a higher order. So the economy keeps solving one challenge and moving to another. The standard of living of one group of people differs from another depending on how far the concerned economy has fulfilled the needs of its population.

This challenge has two aspects. First, the availability of the goods and services required by the population. Second, the presence of a supply network. Every economy must first guarantee the required level of goods and services from its production process. For this, a proper level of production capacity must be built, which needs a particular level of capital formation or investment.

Where the investible funds come from is a separate question. Will the investment come from the government, the domestic private sector or foreigners? Once these details are settled as per the socio-economic condition of the economy, a proper distribution network for the goods and services produced is assured.

Distribution Network Models

There are three historically existing models of distribution network: state, market, and state-market mix.

ModelHow it worksExamples
StateThe state (government) alone supplies the goods and services needed by the population, with no payment by the consumer.Former Soviet Union, Communist China
MarketWorks on the price mechanism. Goods and services are sold in the market; prices are set by demand and supply; then they are distributed to the population.Capitalist economies, the whole of Euro-America
State-market mixSome goods and services are given free or at subsidised prices by the state; others are supplied by the market and paid for by consumers.Most prevalent today; almost all economies follow some version

The state-market mix developed out of the experience of the first two systems. As the socio-economic composition of a population changes, the mix of goods and services supplied by the state and by the market is redefined from time to time.

  • For essential goods and services the government may fix prices, for example the NPPA in the case of stents.
  • For other goods, market forces decide the price.
  • The government may decide who needs how much and distribute accordingly, using subsidy or rationing shops.
  • Presently most nations are mixed economic systems, including the USA and India.
  • China officially claims to be socialist, but in practice it too has become a mixed economy.

Organising an Economy

One issue has affected civilised history the most and remains contentious: how should the production process be organised? Should production be the sole responsibility of the state or government, or should it be left entirely to the private sector? Or is a joint effort, a mixture of state and private enterprises, better?

Depending on the dominant view of the time in a country, different production patterns evolved and different economic systems came up. Three models of economic system evolved in human history. They are stages in the evolutionary process of experiments to find a better way of organising an economy.

1. Capitalistic Economy

The capitalistic form of economy has its origin in Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations (1776). Adam Smith was a Scottish philosopher-economist and professor at the University of Glasgow. His writings formed the basis of classical economics. He raised his voice against the heavy-handed government regulation of commerce and industry of his time, which did not allow the economy to tap its full economic worth and reach well-being.

Smith stressed division of labour and an environment of laissez faire (non-interference by the government). He proposed that the invisible hand of market forces (price mechanism) would bring equilibrium to the economy and general well-being for the countrymen. He acknowledged that competition in the market is needed for such an economy to work for public well-being.

Once the USA attained independence, Adam Smith's ideas were made part of its public policy, just one year after the Wealth of Nations was published. From there the idea spread to other parts of Euro-America. By 1800 the economic system called capitalism was established. It was later known by other names: Private Enterprise System, Free Enterprise System or Market Economy.

In this system, the market and private enterprises decide what to produce, how much to produce and at what price to sell. The state has no economic role.

Important Event: Rise of Capitalism (1776-1800)
  • Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations (1776) laid the basis of capitalism.
  • The USA made Smith's ideas part of public policy one year after the book was published.
  • The idea spread to other parts of Euro-America.
  • By 1800 capitalism was established, also called Private Enterprise System, Free Enterprise System or Market Economy.
  • In a free market economy, the market forces of supply and demand decide what to produce. Essential goods and services are left to the public sector and others to the private sector.
  • In the public sector, the government decides the mode of production. In the private sector there is a preference for labour-intensive modes of production.
  • Anarcho-capitalism was given by the American activist Murray Rothbard in the 1950s.
  • Libertarianism gives supremacy to individual liberty and wants very little government control. Anarchism means a society without government or rulers.
  • Under normal capitalism the private sector has freedom, but the government still controls law and order, contract enforcement and the judiciary.
  • Under anarcho-capitalism every function is done by the private sector, including police stations, and the judiciary is replaced by private arbitrators.
  • Normal capitalism allows taxes on imported goods, while anarcho-capitalism wants no taxes on imported goods and free trade among nations, so that local customers benefit from cheap imported goods.
  • Autarky is an economic system of self-sufficiency and limited trade with the world. A closed economy is 100% autarky because it has no import-export or FDI/FPI relationship with the world; an example is North Korea.
  • Britain's Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher focused on privatisation of government companies and reducing government control.

The idea of absolute cost advantage is linked to Adam Smith. Example: to produce 1 metre of textile, France needs 10 workers and England needs 9 workers; to produce 1 bottle of wine, France needs 12 workers and England needs 8 workers. England needs fewer workers than France for both goods, so under absolute cost advantage England should not import anything from France. But for England the per unit labour cost of making textile is relatively cheaper than making wine. So England should move its wine workers to textiles, export textile to France and import wine from France, instead of trying to become a wine production specialist.

2. State Economy

This system is rooted in the ideas of historical change proposed by the German philosopher Karl Marx (1818-1883). It first came up in the erstwhile USSR after the Bolshevik Revolution (1917) and got its ideal shape in the People's Republic of China (1949). It also spread to other countries of Eastern Europe.

There were two versions of the state economy: the socialist economy in the erstwhile USSR and the communist economy in pre-1985 China.

VersionWhereKey features
Socialist economyErstwhile USSRCollective ownership of the means of production (property and assets); a large role for the state in running the economy.
Communist economyPre-1985 ChinaState ownership of all properties including labour; absolute power of the state in running the economy.

For Marx, socialism was a transitional stage to communism, but this never happened in reality. This form of economy came as a reaction to capitalism and proposed just the opposite. Decisions on production, supply and prices were to be taken solely by the state. Such economies were also called Centralised Economy, Centrally Planned Economy or Non-market Economy.

Socialist and communist economies criticised capitalistic economics as based on exploitation. In reply, capitalist economies called them practitioners of state capitalism, where the state was the sole exploiter. These communist and anti-communist propagandas led to serious intellectual discussions almost up to the mid-1980s.

Important Person: Karl Marx (1818-1883)
  • German philosopher.
  • His ideas of historical change are the root of the state economy.
  • Saw socialism as a transitional stage to communism, though this never happened in reality.
  • The socialist and communist economies were built on his ideas.
Important Event: Bolshevik Revolution (1917)
  • Brought the state economy to power in the erstwhile USSR.
  • The USSR model was the socialist economy, with collective ownership of the means of production.
  • The communist version got its ideal shape in the People's Republic of China (1949).
  • The socialist economic system stopped in most nations after the collapse of the USSR, except a handful of outliers like North Korea, Cuba and Venezuela, and they all suffer from economic hardship.
  • Communism is a branch of socialism, usually run by a totalitarian government made up of one and only one party.

3. Mixed Economy

Belief in the self-correcting quality of the market and Adam Smith's invisible hand got a major setback in the early 20th century during the Great Depression (1929). The depression spread from the USA to other economies of Western Europe. It caused large-scale unemployment, a fall in demand and economic activities, and lockouts in industrial enterprises. The prevailing Smithsonian macro ideas failed to check the crisis.

A new approach was needed. It came in the famous work The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936) by the English economist at Cambridge University, John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946). Keynes questioned the very principles of laissez-faire and the nature of the invisible hand. He said the invisible hand brings equilibrium to the economy but by strangulating the poor. He suggested that prices...

Important Event: Great Depression (1929)
  • Began in the USA and spread to Western Europe.
  • Caused large-scale unemployment, falling demand and economic activity, and lockouts in industry.
  • The prevailing Smithsonian macro ideas failed to check the crisis.
  • It shook belief in the self-correcting market and the invisible hand, opening the way for Keynes's ideas.
Important Person: John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946)
  • English economist at Cambridge University.
  • Wrote The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936).
  • Questioned the principles of laissez-faire and the nature of the invisible hand.
  • Said the invisible hand brings equilibrium but by strangulating the poor.
Common Confusions
  • Economics is the discipline (theory); the economy is the real picture of it in a region or country (practice).
  • Socialism and communism are two versions of the state economy: socialism allows collective ownership, communism means state ownership of all property including labour.
  • Capitalism is also called Private Enterprise System, Free Enterprise System or Market Economy; the state economy is also called Centralised, Centrally Planned or Non-market Economy.
  • Adam Smith is associated with capitalism and the invisible hand; Karl Marx with the state economy; Keynes with the mixed-economy approach after the Great Depression.
Key Facts: Facts to Remember
  • Lionel Robbins (1935): economics is the science of scarcity.
  • Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations: 1776; capitalism established by 1800.
  • Bolshevik Revolution: 1917; People's Republic of China: 1949; pre-1985 China was the communist economy.
  • Great Depression: 1929; Keynes's General Theory: 1936.
  • Three distribution models: state, market, state-market mix.
  • Three economic systems: capitalistic, state, mixed.
  • Economists began studying implementation and delivery systems after the 1960s.
Practice Questions
  • 1. Who described economics as the science of scarcity? a) Adam Smith b) Lionel Robbins c) Karl Marx d) J. M. Keynes. Answer: b. Robbins gave this description in 1935 because resources are always in short supply.
  • 2. Which of the following is NOT a name for the capitalistic economy? a) Free Enterprise System b) Market Economy c) Centrally Planned Economy d) Private Enterprise System. Answer: c. Centrally Planned Economy is a name for the state economy.
  • 3. Assertion (A): No two economies of the world are exactly the same. Reason (R): Economic theories are expectations of human behaviour, which depends on many internal and external factors. a) Both A and R are true and R explains A b) Both true but R does not explain A c) A true, R false d) A false, R true. Answer: a. Differences in natural resources, human resources, socio-political milieu and history make economies diverse.
  • 4. In which system are goods supplied free by the state with no payment by the consumer? a) Market model b) State model c) State-market mix d) None. Answer: b. The former Soviet Union and Communist China are examples of the state model.
  • 5. The Great Depression of 1929 first began in: a) the USSR b) Western Europe c) the USA d) China. Answer: c. It began in the USA and then spread to Western Europe.
  • 6. Short answer: What did Keynes mean by saying the invisible hand brings equilibrium by strangulating the poor? Answer: He meant that market forces may balance the economy but at the cost of the poor, so laissez-faire cannot be trusted to protect them.
  • In a mixed economy, essential goods and services are produced by the public sector and others by the private sector.
  • The government decides what must be produced and in how much quantity.
  • During production, whichever mode of production is cheaper is used.
  • Direct tax is a tax levied directly on an individual's or entity's income, wealth or profits and is paid straight to the government. Its defining feature is that the burden cannot be transferred to another person.
  • Examples of direct taxes are Income Tax, Corporate Tax, Capital Gains Tax and Securities Transaction Tax.
  • In ancient India, taxes were mostly on land, agriculture and trade. Under the Maurya and Gupta empires there was organised revenue collection, with officials overseeing land and produce taxes.
  • Adam Smith gave four canons of taxation: equality, certainty, convenience and economy.
  • Canon of certainty: dates, slabs and rates should be definite and told in advance; the government should not randomly demand a tax.
  • Canon of convenience: the taxpayer should not be made to wait in a kilometre-long queue or fill 50 pages of tax forms.
  • Canon of economy: to collect 100 crore rupees of tax, the government should not spend 99 crore rupees on the salaries of tax officials.
  • Ability to pay principle of taxation holds that the taxes people pay should relate to their income or wealth.
  • Bargaining theory of wages: workers, factory owners and trade unions determine wages through negotiation.
  • Subsistence wage theory is associated with Adam Smith and natural wage theory with David Ricardo.
  • India ratified 6 out of the 8 core conventions of the International Labour Organization.
  • The National Statistical Office collects and analyses data on industries, agriculture and services. It publishes official statistical reports, databases and periodic publications, develops statistical standards, concepts, definitions and classifications for uniformity, gives technical guidance to state statistical departments, ensures data quality through validation and verification, and promotes modern technology and digital tools in data collection and analysis.
  • Land reform is a deliberate intervention in the prevailing patterns of landownership, control and usage. Its objectives are economic (increasing productivity), social (equitable wealth distribution) and political (expanding employment).
  • Land is also a source of political power, so land reform is inherently political. Meaningful reform challenges the power base of elites and needs strong political will and shifts in power.
  • Land reform differs from other reforms because it targets a single sector and involves a fixed tangible asset crucial for livelihoods in developing nations.
  • As populations grow and land remains fixed, old systems of land distribution may not work, leading to the need for land reforms.
  • Economic inequality is the unequal distribution of income and opportunity among different groups in society. It has many dimensions: income, wealth, consumption and opportunity.
  • Income inequality is the extent to which income is distributed unevenly among a population. It relates not only to the flow of income but is linked with the stock of wealth, since the latter generates periodical returns.
  • Wealth inequality is the uneven distribution of financial assets, physical property, gold and so on.
  • Consumption inequality arises from increased income and wealth inequality: the rich consume more in quality and quantity of food, water, shelter, electricity, transport and other material and invisible goods and services.
  • Inequality of opportunity means the well-off have access to good health, education, entertainment and communications, while the same is partly denied to others.
  • A circular economy is an alternative to the traditional linear economy of make, use and dispose. Resources are kept in use for as long as possible, maximum value is extracted from them, and waste is recovered and regenerated at the end.
  • In 2019 NITI Aayog proposed 'Circular Economy and Resource Efficiency in India'.
  • A person who is houseless and lives in a temporary house, where use of dwelling space is insecure and there is lack of access to basic services, is considered residentially vulnerable.
  • A person unemployed for a significant proportion of time, or with irregular employment, or whose work is unsanitary or hazardous, or who has no stability of payment for services, is considered occupationally vulnerable.
  • Cryptocurrencies are primarily held by a few big players called whales, so they can manipulate prices by manipulating supply.
  • Unani medicine came to India in the eighth century.
  • Homoeopathy was founded by the German physician Dr Christian Friedrich Samuel Hahnemann in 1796. In 1810 European missionaries brought it to India, and in 1948 it received official recognition by a Resolution passed by the Constituent Assembly. It works on the principle Similia Similibus Curentur, meaning like cures like.
  • The Siddha system developed among the ancient Tamils or Dravidians in South India during the Indus Valley civilisation. Siddhars are those who achieved perfection in medicine, and the 96 tools or principles of the system are called Thathuvas. Siddha literature covers science of life, drugs, kayakalpam, anatomy, physiology, pathology, diagnostic parameters, surgery, alchemy, astrology and atomic theory.

1.2Mixed Economy and Role of State

Keynes and the Great Depression

Keynes questioned the market mechanism because wages and prices are not flexible enough to provide employment to all. Even at full potential, some people remain unemployed. A fall in demand leads to recession and, if unchecked, to depression, as happened in 1929. Keynes suggested strong government intervention. To come out of depression, he advised increasing government expenditure and using discretionary fiscal policy (fiscal deficit, lower interest rates, cheap money supply) to boost demand for goods and services. Keynesian policies successfully pulled economies out of the Great Depression.

Important Person: John Maynard Keynes (1883–1946)
  • British economist who questioned the capitalist system during the Great Depression.
  • Argued that wages are not flexible, so unemployment can persist even at full potential.
  • Suggested strong government intervention through higher public spending and fiscal policy.
  • His ideas led to the mixed economy and active state role in the economy.

Keynesian model (1936): An economy's output equals the sum of four components — consumption, investment, government purchases, and net exports (CIGXM). If GDP falls, the government should influence it by increasing expenditure (counter-cyclical fiscal policy).

  • Solow Paradox (1987): Nobel winner Robert Solow noted computers were everywhere but were not boosting productivity.
  • The paradox was later proved correct by the USA dot-com crash (2000), when share prices of IT/tech companies collapsed, causing a loss of $5 trillion to investors.
  • Critics argue the same may happen with an AI bubble in future.

Keynes's Critique of Capitalism

Keynes questioned the capitalist economic system of Euro-America. He suggested that capitalism should assimilate some goals of the socialist economy (the ex-USSR). In capitalist economies, all basic goods and services were part of the market mechanism, produced and supplied by the private sector. This led to an undimensional movement of money and wealth from the masses to a few who controlled production and supply. The masses faced pauperisation every day, weakening their purchasing power. This affected overall demand and culminated in the Great Depression.

Public Goods and the Rise of Mixed Economy

Following Keynesian advice, many trendsetting economic policies were initiated in capitalist economies. One important initiative was the government's active role in the economy. Governments started producing and supplying some basic goods and services known as 'public goods'. These included minimum nutrition, healthcare, sanitation, education, and social security. Expenditure on public goods was incurred on the public exchequer, even if it required deficit financing. From the 1930s to the 1950s, almost 50 per cent of GDP in Euro-America was spent by governments on public goods, which became popular as the social sector. Goods and services earlier purchased as 'private goods' were now made available by the state 'free-of-costs', giving people spare money to create demand for market goods. This shows how capitalism redefined itself by including traits of the non-market (state) economy. Thus the mixed economy arrived and challenged the classical capitalistic economy.

Oscar Lange and Market Socialism

Oscar Lange (1904–65), a Polish philosopher, in the 1950s suggested for the socialist economy what Keynes had suggested for the capitalist economy. Lange praised the state economy but also suggested including some good things of the capitalistic economy. He advised state economies to adopt 'market socialism' (a term he coined). His suggestions were outrightly rejected by state economies as such compromises were considered blasphemous at that time (seen as a suggestion towards democracy from dictatorship). Just as Keynes suggested that capitalism should move a few steps towards socialism, Lange suggested the same for state economies. Democracies are flexible and were able to experiment, which paid off later. But socialist and communist political systems were stubborn and did not experiment, leading to their economic decay.

Important Person: Oscar Lange (1904–65)
  • Polish philosopher and economist.
  • Coined the term 'market socialism' in the 1950s.
  • Suggested that state economies should adopt some features of capitalism, just as Keynes suggested capitalism adopt some socialism.
  • His ideas were rejected by state economies at the time but later adopted by China.

China's Open Door Policy and Transition

The first opinion against total state economic control came from communist China under Mao Tse-tung. China, the ultimate example of a state economy, started preparing for a limited market economy under a dictatorship. In 1985, China announced its 'open door policy', the first experiment in 'market socialism'—Lange had the last laugh. Other state economies followed, though unprepared. The switch to market socialism was not smooth for most. In the Soviet Union, efforts towards market socialism, fuelled by 'glasnost' (openness) and 'perestroika' (restructuring), resulted in the disintegration of the nation-state. Experts consider it 'a political fallout of an economic mismanagement'. Other state economies experienced major economic breakdowns during transition. Smooth transition required prerequisites to be in place beforehand. China had done this homework since Mao's time (especially since 1975), emerging as the real winner—the ideal type example of a state economy smoothly metamorphosing into a giant market economy.

Important Event: China's Open Door Policy (1985)
  • China announced its 'open door policy' in 1985.
  • It was the first experiment in 'market socialism' as suggested by Oscar Lange.
  • China had prepared since 1975 under Mao, making the transition smooth.
  • It became the ideal example of a state economy transforming into a market economy.

Mixed Economy in the Post-War Period

These two events spanning many decades were timely and rational selections of economic traits from each other's systems. By the late 1980s, the world had neither a pure capitalistic economy nor a pure state economy. Many states opted for a mixed economy in the post-Second World War period after coming out of colonial rule, such as India, Malaysia, Indonesia, etc. Their leadership could be considered visionaries, proved by the mid-1990s.

World Bank's Endorsement of Mixed Economy

Though the world looked flat for the mixed economy model, a formal opinion on its viability was yet to emerge. The first authoritative opinion came from the World Bank (WB), which accepted the goodness and need of 'state intervention' in the economy. This was a turning point as the WB and IMF were ardent votaries of the free market. The concluding consensus emerged with the World Development Report (1999) titled Entering the 21st Century, in which the WB said, "Governments play a vital role in development, but there is no simple set of rules that tells them what to do." The WB suggested that every country should determine the areas and extent of market and state intervention depending on its stage of economic development, socio-political and historical factors. The report rejected both the free-market economy and the state economy—meaning Adam Smith and Karl Marx were cancelled and rejected outrightly based on historical experiences. Instead, it advocated a 'mixture' of both, i.e., the mixed economy. The long-standing ideological dilemma was solved: the document pinpointed good things of both systems and concluded that they are not dichotomous but complementary. The real issue is not whether to have market or state but having both together. Market economy might suit one economy but not another due to different socio-economic conditions. Similarly, the state economy model might serve one but not another. The real answer is neither market nor state but a judicious mix of both. As the state-market mix depends on socio-economic and political conditions, there can never be a mechanical prototype of the mixed economy applicable universally. Every economy needs to explore its own mixture. The same state might need to redefine the composition of the state-market mix over time according to changed scenarios.

Important Event: World Development Report 1999
  • Published by the World Bank, titled Entering the 21st Century.
  • Accepted the need for state intervention in the economy.
  • Rejected both pure free-market and pure state economy, advocating a mixed economy.
  • Said governments play a vital role but no simple rules exist; countries must decide their own mix.

India's Mixed Economy and Economic Reforms

The process of economic reforms in India started in 1991. It was a search for a new 'state-market mix', while India had been a mixed economy since Independence. After Independence, India opted for a mixed economy when the state-market dilemma was at its peak globally. The state took up basic infrastructural responsibilities, and the rest was left to private enterprises. This state-market mix was thought fit for the socio-economic and political conditions of the time. Once reforms started in the early 1990s, the prevailing mix was redefined and a new form of mixed economy began. The redefined mixed economy had a declared favour for the market economy. Many economic roles under complete government monopoly were opened to the private sector—telecommunication, power, roads, oil and natural gas, etc. At the same time, responsibilities that only the state could shoulder were given extra emphasis—the whole social sector: education, healthcare, drinking water, sanitation, nutrition, social security, etc. India's economic system was a mixed economy in pre-1991 and post-1991 years, but the composition of the state-market mix changed. In future, as socio-economic and political factors change, India will redefine its mixed economy accordingly.

Settling the Debate: From Adam Smith to WTO

The emergence and evolution of the mixed economy settled the long-standing debate on the best way to organise an economy. Starting in 1776 with Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, it continued till the World Development Report 1999 by the WB. The dilemma continued for almost two and a quarter centuries (1776–2000). Today, the WTO has taken over the world economy, and the brand of mixed economy it advocates is more inclined towards the free market economy. However, it does not propagate making the state an economic non-entity; it leaves scope for greater state intervention in required areas if needed.

GATT trade rounds and their years:

RoundYearsPlace/Note
Dillon Round1960–1961Geneva
Kennedy Round1962–1967Held in Geneva but named after US President John F. Kennedy
Tokyo Round1973–1979—
Uruguay Round1986–94Longest round under GATT
  • The Uruguay Round lasted the longest under GATT because the world was undergoing basic changes in how economies were managed.
  • Industrial democracies were becoming more acceptable to developing countries.
  • China was adopting LPG policies in a historic manner.
  • The communist model of economy was losing value.
  • Developing countries were rethinking their protectionist policies.
  • The USSR was disintegrating, leaving the third world weak in bargaining terms.

Role of the State in an Economy

The search for the ideal way of organising an economy also solved the riddle of the role of the state. Looking back at economic history, there are three possible roles for the state/government in an economy:

  • As a regulator of the economic system: the state takes important economic decisions, announces policies, implements them, and controls and punishes those who don't oblige.
  • As a producer and/or supplier of 'private goods and services': these are goods that are part of the market and distributed according to market principles. Here the state earns profit as a private enterprise.
  • As a producer and/or supplier of 'public goods' or 'social goods': these include goods essential from the perspective of social justice and well-being—education, healthcare, sanitation, drinking water, nutrition, care for the differently abled and old, etc. These are generally distributed free of cost or at subsidised prices. The loss is paid out of the public exchequer, meaning the whole economy pays for the cause of a few people.

Different economies select different roles for the state according to their socio-political ideologies, resulting in different economic systems. On regulating the economy, there has been no debate—all economic systems are regulated by the state only. But the selection of the other two functions made the real difference. Economies that selected both roles (ii and iii) for the state under monopoly were called state economies. This category had two variants: socialist economy (where labour was not owned and exploited by the state) and communist economy (where labour was under complete state control). These economies had almost no market. The economic system that left both roles (ii and iii) to the private sector was called the capitalistic economic system. Here the state had almost no economic role but played a passive role as regulator. Mixed economies kept at least one economic role fixed for the state (i.e., iii), supplying public goods to the needy. In some mixed economies, the state also took some roles of supplying private goods (i.e., ii), even carrying a heavy burden of subsidies.

The WB document—World Development Report 1999—was a judgement on the suitable role of the state, suggesting timely shuffling of the state's role as per socio-economic and political needs. Keynes said the political problem of mankind is to combine three things: (i) economic efficiency, (ii) social justice, and (iii) individual liberty. To realise these objectives, an economy cannot allow only the state's role or only the market's role. These challenges can be faced properly only when both state and market are given a balanced role—the balance to be defined by present conditions and future goals. Striking the right balance between the state and the market came to be known as the process of economic reform in the post-WTO world.

One expert view on the state's role in development came in a keynote address at the Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics, 1996, titled 'The Role of Government in Economic Development'. It gives a short and clear idea on the issue.

Compulsory Roles for the State

Analysing the need of an economy, some roles are compulsory for the state:

  • Regulation and control: if left to private individuals or groups (firms), they will use regulatory powers to maximise their profits at the cost of others. That is why this role must rest with the state. It is more logical in a democratic set-up, where the interest of the largest numbers is represented.
  • Producing and distributing private goods: this profit-fetching area can be well handled by the private sector. The state should not burden itself. But in the absence of a proper private sector, many countries gave this responsibility to the state; India is one among them. As the private sector became capable, some countries gave up this responsibility in favour of the private sector, leading to better development. India delayed this process, while Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand and South Korea allowed private sector entry much earlier.
  • Producing and supplying social/public goods: this loss-making exercise cannot be left to the private sector. The state must take sole responsibility or expand its role—as seen in post-reform India.

As the private sector becomes capable of producing and supplying private goods, the state saves its human and economic resources, which are transferred to public goods production and distribution. The WB study, The East Asian Miracle (1993), recognises this shift from one kind of mixed economy to another in Malaysia, Thailand and South Korea since the mid-1960s. Experts believe this shift could not take place in time in India. When it started (1991–92), it was too late and the choice was not voluntary but obligatory. The East Asian economies had gone for the same reform process but by their choice.

Important Event: The East Asian Miracle (1993)
  • A World Bank study.
  • Recognised the shift from one kind of mixed economy to another in Malaysia, Thailand and South Korea since the mid-1960s.
  • These countries allowed private sector entry earlier and reformed by choice.
  • India delayed this shift; its 1991 reforms were obligatory, not voluntary.

Washington Consensus

The term 'Washington Consensus' was coined by the US economist John Williamson in 1989. He suggested a set of policy reforms that most officials in Washington (IMF and World Bank) thought would be good for crisis-driven Latin American countries. The policy reforms included ten propositions:

  • Fiscal discipline
  • A redirection of public expenditure priorities toward fields offering both high economic returns and the potential to improve income distribution, such as primary health care, primary education, and infrastructure.

The remaining eight propositions are not detailed in the source, but the ten propositions form the Washington Consensus.

Important Person: John Williamson (1937–2021)
  • US economist who coined the term 'Washington Consensus' in 1989.
  • Suggested a set of ten policy reforms for crisis-driven Latin American countries.
  • The reforms were favoured by the IMF and World Bank.
  • The first two propositions are fiscal discipline and redirection of public expenditure.
Common Confusions
  • Mixed economy is not a fixed model; its composition changes with time and conditions.
  • Public goods are not the same as private goods; public goods are provided by the state, often free or subsidised.
  • State economies had two variants: socialist and communist; in socialist, labour was not owned by the state, in communist it was.
  • Washington Consensus was coined by John Williamson, not by Washington institutions, though it reflected their views.
Key Facts: Facts to Memorise
  • Great Depression: 1929.
  • Keynesian policies followed from 1930s to 1950s; about 50% of GDP in Euro-America spent on public goods.
  • Oscar Lange: 1904–65, coined 'market socialism' in 1950s.
  • China's open door policy: 1985.
  • World Development Report 1999: Entering the 21st Century.
  • India's economic reforms: 1991.
  • Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations: 1776.
  • Washington Consensus: coined by John Williamson in 1989; ten propositions.
  • The East Asian Miracle: WB study, 1993.
Practice Questions
  • 1. Who coined the term 'market socialism'? a) Keynes b) Oscar Lange c) John Williamson d) Adam Smith. Answer: b. Oscar Lange, a Polish philosopher, coined the term in the 1950s.
  • 2. The Washington Consensus was coined in which year? a) 1985 b) 1989 c) 1991 d) 1999. Answer: b. 1989, by John Williamson.
  • 3. Assertion: The World Development Report 1999 rejected both pure market and pure state economies. Reason: It advocated a mixed economy based on a country's specific conditions. a) Both true, reason explains assertion b) Both true, reason does not explain c) Assertion true, reason false d) Assertion false, reason true. Answer: a. The report rejected both and advocated a mixed economy tailored to each country.
  • 4. Which of the following is NOT a public good? a) Education b) Healthcare c) Telecommunication d) Sanitation. Answer: c. Telecommunication is a private good, often provided by the market.
  • 5. Short answer: What are the three roles of the state in an economy according to the source? Answer: (i) regulator, (ii) producer/supplier of private goods, (iii) producer/supplier of public goods.
  • 6. Short answer: Why did India's 1991 reforms differ from East Asian reforms? Answer: India's reforms were obligatory and late, while East Asian countries reformed by choice earlier.
  • Washington Consensus (1980s): a set of economic policy recommendations for developing countries, especially Latin America, given by the IMF, World Bank and the US Department of the Treasury during the 1980s.
  • Its focus areas were similar to LPG reforms — reduce government control.
  • Reaganomics (1980s): by US President Reagan; focus on reducing government spending and control and giving tax cuts to businessmen.
  • Thatcherism (1980s): a similar set of policies from the same period.

1.3Washington Consensus, Sectors and National Income

The Washington Consensus: The Ten-Point Prescription

The Washington Consensus was a set of ten policy prescriptions. The earlier points (not repeated here) covered fiscal discipline, public spending on areas with high economic returns and better income distribution (primary health care, primary education, infrastructure), and tax reform to lower marginal rates and broaden the tax base. The remaining points are listed below.

  • Interest rate liberalisation
  • A competitive exchange rate
  • Trade liberalisation
  • Liberalisation of FDI inflows
  • Privatisation
  • Deregulation, meaning abolition of barriers to entry and exit
  • Secure property rights

In later times the term became a synonym for neo-liberalism (in Latin America), for market fundamentalism (as George Soros said in 1998), and even for globalisation across the world. It is often used to describe an extreme and dogmatic belief that markets can handle everything.

The reality was different. The set of policies was already being recommended by the IMF and the World Bank together with the US Treasury, especially during the eighties and early nineties. The prescription was originally meant to solve the real problems of Latin America at that time. Its later use to handle a wide array of other situations has been criticised even by the original proponents of the policies. Its creator himself has called the name Washington Consensus somewhat unfortunate.

Important Person: John Williamson
  • The economist who coined the term Washington Consensus.
  • He says audiences worldwide believe the term means a set of neo-liberal policies imposed on helpless countries by Washington-based international financial institutions, leading them to crisis and misery.
  • He notes many people feel it suggests rules imposed on developing nations by the United States.
  • He always felt the prescription represented a consensus precisely because the points were so universal.
  • Many proponents see it not as a hard-line neo-liberal agenda but as a relatively conservative assessment of policies that can bring a country to economic stability.

The policy prescription led to the processes known as Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation (LPG). This cut down the role of the State in the economy, more so in nations that got developmental funding from the World Bank or went to the IMF during Balance of Payment crises. India is an example: it began its reform process in 1991 under the conditions of the IMF. It was as if Adam Smith's prescription of the free market (liberalism) had taken rebirth as neo-liberalism.

Many scholars today believe the recent financial crises of the US and European nations are somehow born out of the ideas rooted in the Consensus. After the Great Recession (following the US sub-prime crisis) in Western economies, it is believed that dependence on the market to correct growth and development may not sustain any longer. The world might agree in favour of a development state, as in the East Asian nations, which never went for the Consensus for their robust growth. The Keynesian idea of an interventionist state seems the ultimate alternative in present times, as suggested by the US Nobel economist Paul Krugman and followed by the Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (the Three Arrows of Abenomics).

Important Event: India's Reform Process (1991)
  • India commenced its reform process in 1991 under the conditions of the IMF.
  • It came during a Balance of Payments crisis.
  • The reforms followed the LPG path, cutting the role of the State in the economy.
  • Critics call Indian economic policies neo-liberal because of this IMF-linked, Washington Consensus influence.

A Balance of Payments (BoP) crisis, also called a currency crisis, happens when a country cannot pay for essential imports or repay foreign debt. It often comes after a period of heavy capital inflows that boost growth, followed by a sudden withdrawal of foreign investment. The currency value then falls fast, which hurts firms that earn in domestic currency but must repay debts in foreign currency. Governments may respond by raising interest rates or asking for international help.

The IMF gives financial help to countries with BoP deficits so they can carry out adjustment policies and reforms and stabilise the economy.

  • India now gives international aid, for example a $1 billion loan to Sri Lanka, as unconditional help, in contrast to IMF loans that come with conditions based on the Washington Consensus.
  • The Washington Consensus is a policy that seeks intervention in the market.
  • Autarky generally means economic self-sufficiency.
  • Adam Smith called the market or price mechanism the 'invisible hand'.

After the 1991 reforms, India's growth helped reduce poverty, though income inequality became more pronounced. A World Bank report says India moved 170 million people out of poverty between 2011-12 and 2022-23, a notable fall in extreme poverty. India also integrated with the global economy, joined the WTO and G20, and signed several free trade agreements, boosting exports.

  • Fixed assets are assets used in business for more than one accounting year; they are also called depreciable assets, for example machines, plants, furniture, buildings, computers, trucks, vans and equipment.
  • Depreciation is the decline in the value of a fixed asset.
  • Depreciation is caused by wear and tear from use, passage of time, arrival of a new machine or model (obsolescence), and exposure to natural things like weather, winds, rains and moisture.
  • Depletion is like depreciation but for natural resources such as mines and quarries.
  • Amortisation is like depreciation but for intangible assets such as patents, copyrights, trade marks, franchises and goodwill.
  • Depreciation is a non-cash expense, and it must be charged to find the true profit or loss of a business.

Sectors of an Economy

Every economy tries to maximise the returns of the economic activities in which it is involved. Whatever the organising principles of an economy, its economic activities are broadly classified into three categories, known as the three sectors of the economy.

SectorAlso calledActivities included
PrimaryAgricultural sector (in India)Direct use of natural resources: agriculture, forestry, fishing, fuels, metals, minerals
SecondaryManufacturing or industrial sectorUses the produce of the primary sector as raw material: bread, biscuits, cakes, automobiles, textiles
TertiaryServices sectorProduction of services: education, banking, insurance, transportation, tourism

In some economies mining is treated as part of the secondary sector even though it uses natural resources directly. Broadly, such economies call their agricultural sector the primary sector. This is the case in India.

Some lists add two more sectors. The quaternary sector covers knowledge-based activities, and the quinary sector covers top-level decision-making. Economies are also grouped as organised and unorganised, and as public and private.

The primary sector is dominant in underdeveloped economies and gives the largest share of national income, but it is limited because it depends on land, a fixed factor of production, and diminishing returns set in early.

The secondary sector comes after the primary sector. Its goods cannot be produced by nature and must be manufactured, for example a plant that turns steel and rubber into cars.

The tertiary sector does not produce goods but helps production, trade and consumption. Exchange covers trade, transport and communication, which help overcome distance.

SectorShare in GVA (%) 2022-232023-242024-252025-26
Primary22.121.521.419.8
Secondary26.026.125.825.9
Tertiary51.952.452.854.3
  • In GVA, the primary sector includes agriculture, livestock, forestry and fishing, and mining and quarrying.
  • The secondary sector includes manufacturing; electricity, gas, water supply and other utilities; and construction.
  • The tertiary sector includes trade, hotels, transport, communication and broadcasting, storage; financial, real estate, IT and professional services; ownership of dwelling; and public administration, defence and other services.
  • The secondary sector contributes about 25.3 to 28.7 per cent of GDP/GVA and employs about 23 to 25 per cent of workers.
  • The tertiary sector contributes about 55 to 60 per cent of GVA and employs about 27 to 30 per cent of the workforce.
  • India shifted from the agriculture-dominated primary sector straight to the service sector, largely skipping the industrial phase.

The economy is also divided into core sectors. The eight core sectors of the Indian economy are coal, crude oil, natural gas, refinery products, fertilisers, steel, cement and electricity.

Modern lists sometimes name five sectors: primary, secondary, tertiary, quaternary (knowledge-based) and quinary (human services).

  • With 4.6 per cent of all services traded globally, India ranks seventh in the world as a commercial service exporter as of 2023.
  • Imports are not always bad if a country imports raw materials or intermediate products to boost manufacturing and exports.
  • Heavy imports can make the currency depreciate because more foreign currency is needed for them; this makes imports costlier, worsens the deficit, raises external debt, depletes foreign exchange reserves and can scare away foreign investors.
  • The trade deficit can be cut by boosting exports, reducing unnecessary imports, developing domestic industries, and managing currency and debt levels well.
PYQ · UPSC Prelims 2024

Consider the following economic activities: Activity - Sector
1. Storage of agricultural produce - Secondary
2. Dairy farming - Primary
3. Mineral exploration - Tertiary
4. Weaving of cloth - Secondary.
How many of the above pairs are correctly matched?

  1. Only one
  2. Only two
  3. Only three
  4. All four

Answer: (b) Only two

The correct answer is 'Only two'. See the question statements above for the specific facts tested on this Sectors of the Indian Economy question.

Types of Economies

Economies are categorised by the share of a particular sector in total production and by the ratio of the dependent population that draws its livelihood from that sector.

  • Agrarian economy: the primary sector's share is 50 per cent or more of total output (GDP).
  • Industrial economy: the secondary sector contributes 50 per cent or more of total produce value. The higher the contribution, the higher the level of industrialisation.
  • Service economy: 50 per cent or more of produced value comes from the tertiary sector. The tertiary sector gives livelihood to the largest number of people in such economies.

At the time of Independence, India was an agrarian economy. Now it shows the symptoms of a service economy: the primary sector's contribution has fallen to almost 18 per cent of total produce, while almost 49 per cent of the population still depends on the primary sector for livelihood. So in monetary terms India is no longer an agrarian economy, but the dependency ratio makes it so. India is the first such example in the economic history of the world.

The Western economies that industrialised early earned faster income and developed early; they are known as developed economies. Most of them crossed the industrial phase once industrialisation saturated. The first lot of service economies in the world were these early industrialised economies.

In the last decade (2003-04 to 2012-13), growth increasingly came from the services sector. Its contribution to the overall growth of the economy was 65 per cent, while industry contributed 27 per cent and agriculture 8 per cent.

SectorShare in overall growth, 2003-04 to 2012-13
Services (tertiary)65 per cent
Industry (secondary)27 per cent
Agriculture (primary)8 per cent

By the end of the 19th century it was well established, at least in the Western world, that industrial activities were a faster way to earn income than agrarian activities. The Second World War established this fact for the whole world, and almost every country began preparing for industrialisation. As country after country industrialised, a pattern of population shift occurred from one sector to another. This is known as the stages of growth of an economy.

With intensifying industrialisation, dependence on the primary sector for livelihood fell and dependence on the secondary sector rose consistently. Later, these economies saw a population shift from the secondary to the tertiary sector; such economies are called post-industrial societies or service societies. Almost the whole of Euro-America falls in this category: over 50 per cent of total produce value comes from the tertiary sector and over half the population depends on it for livelihood. Many countries that began industrialising in the post-war period showed aberrations in this shift of population and income. India is one of them.

Trap: Agrarian or Not?
  • India's primary sector gives only about 18 per cent of output, so in monetary terms India is not agrarian.
  • But about 49 per cent of people depend on the primary sector, so by dependency ratio India is still agrarian.
  • This makes India the first such example in world economic history.
  • Do not confuse the output share with the livelihood share; both are needed to classify an economy.
  • A tiger economy is one of several fast-growing economies, mainly in Southeast Asia such as Singapore, Hong Kong, South Korea and Taiwan. In the 1980s and 1990s they drew large FDI and grew fast, but faced a crisis in 1997 due to a flight of foreign capital.
  • Vietnam aims to reach tiger economy status by 2045.

Latest: The World Bank has published the World Development Report every year since 1978, and it classifies nations as high income and low income.

The Idea of National Income

Income is probably the most frequently used term in economics, by experts and lay people alike. Income level is the most commonly used tool to judge the well-being and happiness of nations and their citizens, even today, even though income is not an exhaustive idea of society's well-being. There is a reason for this perception. When the idea of human development came into being in the early 1990s, the Human Development Index turned out to be heavily dependent on the income level of an individual in a country. Education and life expectancy can be enhanced only when the required investment (expenditure on them) can be mobilised. Thus income came to be established as the focal point of development and human development.

As the income of a single person can be measured, it can be measured for a nation and for the whole world, though the accounting method may be more complex in the latter case. In due course, four ways to calculate the income of a nation developed; they are the subject matter of national income accounting. These four concepts are GDP, NDP, GNP and NNP. All are forms of national income but differ from one another, and each tells a different story about the income of a nation.

Important Person: Simon Kuznets
  • Nobel Prize winning economist from the USA.
  • He first conceived the idea of GDP in 1934.
  • His idea became the base of national income accounting.
  • Private consumption is about 60 per cent of India's GDP, while Gross Fixed Capital Formation (GFCF) is only about 31 per cent.
  • China's GFCF has stayed above 40 per cent, while India's GFCF never crossed 35 per cent between 2001 and 2023.
  • The government raises its own capital expenditure to 'crowd in' private investment by creating demand and improving infrastructure.
  • Developing economies are now senders of FDI as well as receivers; their share of global FDI outflows rose from about 7 per cent in 2000 to about 30 per cent in 2024, for example Tata buying Jaguar Land Rover in the UK.
  • Outward FDI is bad for domestic investment in the short run because capital goes abroad, but good in the long run.

GDP

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the value of all final goods and services produced within the boundary of a nation during a one-year period. For India, this year runs from 1st April to 31st March.

GDP is also calculated by adding national private consumption, gross investment, government spending and the trade balance (exports minus imports). Using exports minus imports removes expenditure on imports not produced in the nation, and adds expenditure on goods and services produced but exported rather than sold within the country.

The terms in the concept mean the following. Gross means the same in Economics and Commerce as total means in Mathematics. Domestic means all economic activities done within the boundary of a nation and by its own capital. Product is used to define goods and services together. Final means the stage of a product after which there is no known chance of value addition in it.

  • The per annum percentage change in GDP is the growth rate of an economy. For example, if a country has a GDP of Rs. 107, which is 7 rupees higher than last year, it has a growth rate of 7 per cent. A growing economy means the economy is adding to its income, in quantitative terms.
  • GDP is a quantitative concept. Its volume or size indicates the internal strength of the economy, but it says nothing about the qualitative aspects of the goods and services produced.
  • It is used by the IMF and World Bank in comparative analyses of their member nations.

GDP can also be measured as Gross Value Added (GVA). GDP is the total value of final goods and services at market prices and includes indirect taxes; it is a demand-side indicator. GVA is the value added by each producer or sector at basic prices, excludes indirect taxes, and is a supply-side indicator. GVA clearly shows the contribution of agriculture, industry and services, while GDP does not directly show it.

GVA equals the value of final output minus intermediate goods, or the sum of value added at each stage. For example, final value 16 lakh minus intermediate 6 lakh gives GVA of 10 lakh, which also equals 1 + 4 + 5 lakh added at each stage.

Domestic territory includes the political boundaries of the country, all land area, internal waters and airspace; territorial waters up to the legal maritime boundary; embassies and consulates abroad; ships and aircraft operated by residents even in international waters or airspace; and offshore installations such as oil rigs run by residents.

Nominal GDP is the value of final goods and services measured at current market prices of the same year.

  • GDP ignores non-marketed activities, such as domestic work done by a mother.
  • GDP ignores opportunity cost: a child labourer making firecrackers worth Rs 50,000 a year adds to GDP, but the income the child could have earned as a doctor or engineer is not counted.
  • Imports are subtracted when calculating GDP.
  • Net factor payments earned from abroad are not included in GDP.
  • Purchase and sale of second-hand goods are not included in GDP.
  • Inventories are included in Gross Domestic Capital Formation.
  • An Indian citizen's income from an investment abroad is part of India's national income but not part of India's GDP.

Peter Wood in the 1980s proposed Green accounting and Green GDP to include environmental costs. In 2021 Uttarakhand became the first Indian state to count Gross Environment Product (GEP) while calculating its GSDP, giving monetary value to the quality and quantity of forest, air, water and soil. If GEP falls year after year, it signals environmental degradation and puts pressure on the state government to act.

Potential growth is the maximum sustainable rate an economy can grow when capital, labour and technology all perform optimally. Actual growth is current performance. The difference is the output gap; a negative gap means resources are idle.

Latest: The tertiary sector's share in GVA rose to 54.3 per cent in 2025-26, with the primary sector at 19.8 per cent and the secondary sector at 25.9 per cent.

GDP can be calculated in three ways: the expenditure method, the GVA or production method, and the income method. When the three methods give different answers, the gap is called a discrepancy. A reform in 2026 fixed this problem.

PYQ · UPSC Prelims 2013

The national income of a country for a given period is equal to the

  1. total value of goods and services produced by the nationals
  2. sum of total consumption and investment expenditure
  3. sum of personal income of all individuals
  4. money value of final goods and service produced

Answer: (d) money value of final goods and service produced

National income represents the total economic value of all final goods and services produced by a nation's residents within a specific period, regardless of location. This is the standard economic definition used in national accounting.

NDP

Net Domestic Product (NDP) is GDP calculated after adjusting the weight of the value of depreciation. It is the net form of GDP: GDP minus the total value of wear and tear (depreciation) that happened in assets while goods and services were being produced. Every asset except human beings depreciates in use, meaning it wears and tears.

Governments decide and announce the rates at which assets depreciate, and a list is published. In India this is done by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. Different sections of the economy use the list to determine real depreciation levels of different assets. For example, a residential house in India has a depreciation rate of 1 per cent per annum, and an electric fan has 10 per cent per annum, calculated in terms of the asset's price. This is one way depreciation is used in economics.

The second use is in the external sector when the domestic currency floats freely against foreign currencies. If the value of the domestic currency falls through the market mechanism compared with a foreign currency, it is a situation of depreciation of the domestic currency, measured as the loss in its value.

Thus NDP = GDP minus Depreciation. NDP of an economy is always lower than its GDP for the same year, since depreciation cannot be cut to zero. Mankind has achieved much here through developments such as ball-bearings and lubricants, all innovated to minimise depreciation levels.

  • For domestic use only: to understand the historical situation of loss due to depreciation in the economy, and to analyse the sectoral situation of depreciation in industry and trade across comparative periods.
  • To show the economy's achievements in research and development, which have tried to cut depreciation levels over a historical period.

NDP is not used in comparative economics, that is, to compare the economies of the world. Why? Because different economies set different rates of depreciation. The rates may be based on logic, as for houses in India: cement, bricks, sand and iron rods used to build houses in India can last 100 years, so the rate is fixed at 1 per cent per annum. But the rates may not always be logical. Up to February 2000, the depreciation rate for heavy vehicles (six wheels and above) was 20 per cent; it was raised to 40 per cent afterwards to boost the sales of heavy vehicles in the country. There was no logic in doubling the rate. Basically, depreciation and its rates are also used by modern governments as a tool of economic policymaking. This is the third way depreciation is used in economics.

Trap: Two Kinds of Depreciation
  • In national income accounting, depreciation means wear and tear of assets used in production.
  • In the external sector, depreciation means a fall in the value of the domestic currency against foreign currencies.
  • A third use is policy: governments change depreciation rates to influence behaviour, e.g., doubling the rate for heavy vehicles from 20 to 40 per cent after February 2000.
  • NDP is always less than GDP for the same year.

GNP

Gross National Product (GNP) is the GDP of a country plus its income from abroad. Here the trans-boundary economic activities of an economy are also taken into account. Three items are counted in the income from abroad segment.

  • Private remittances: the net outcome of money flowing in and out on account of private transfers by Indian nationals working outside India (to India) and foreign nationals working in India (to their home countries). India has always been a gainer on this front: till the early 1990s from the Gulf region, which fell afterwards due to heavy country-bound movements of Indians working there after the Gulf War, and afterwards from the USA and other European nations. Today India is the highest recipient of private remittances in the world, projected by the World Bank at $72 billion in 2015 (in 2013 it was $70 billion, the year's highest). China is second at $64 billion in 2015.
  • Interest on external loans: the net outcome of interest payments, that is, the balance of inflow (on money lent out by the economy) and outflow (on money borrowed by the economy). For India this has always been negative, as the economy is a net borrower from world economies.
  • External grants: the net outcome of external grants flowing to and from India. Today India offers more such grants than it receives. India receives grants (grants or loan-grant mix) from a few countries and UN bodies such as the UNDP, and offers several developmental and humanitarian grants to foreign nations. With globalisation, grant outflows from India have increased as its economic diplomacy aims at playing a bigger role internationally.

The balance of all three components of income from abroad may be positive or negative. In India's case it has always been negative, due to heavy outflows on account of trade deficits and interest payments on foreign loans. This means income from abroad is subtracted from India's GDP to calculate its GNP.

Key Facts: Recall: Key Figures
  • India's financial year: 1 April to 31 March.
  • Primary sector share in India's output: about 18 per cent; population dependent on it: about 49 per cent.
  • Growth contribution 2003-04 to 2012-13: services 65 per cent, industry 27 per cent, agriculture 8 per cent.
  • Depreciation rates in India: residential house 1 per cent per annum; electric fan 10 per cent per annum.
  • Heavy vehicle depreciation rate raised from 20 to 40 per cent after February 2000.
  • Private remittances: India $72 billion in 2015 (highest), China $64 billion; India $70 billion in 2013.
  • GDP idea first conceived by Simon Kuznets in 1934.
Practice Questions
  • 1. Which of the following is NOT part of the ten-point Washington Consensus as described? a) Interest rate liberalisation b) Secure property rights c) Deregulation d) Nationalisation of banks. Answer: d. Nationalisation is the opposite of privatisation, which is part of the Consensus.
  • 2. Assertion (A): India is no longer an agrarian economy in monetary terms. Reason (R): About 49 per cent of India's population still depends on the primary sector for livelihood. a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A c) A is true but R is false d) A is false but R is true. Answer: b. A is true because the primary sector gives only about 18 per cent of output; R is true but explains why India is still agrarian by dependency ratio, not why it is not agrarian in monetary terms.
  • 3. NDP is not used for comparing economies of the world mainly because: a) NDP data are not published b) depreciation rates differ across countries and may be set for policy reasons c) NDP is always higher than GDP d) NDP ignores the services sector. Answer: b. Different countries set different depreciation rates, sometimes without logic, as with heavy vehicles in India.
  • 4. Which item is subtracted from India's GDP to arrive at its GNP? a) Private remittances b) External grants c) The net income from abroad, which is negative for India d) Depreciation. Answer: c. India's income from abroad is negative due to trade deficits and interest payments on foreign loans, so it is subtracted.
  • 5. Short answer: Explain the three ways in which the term depreciation is used in economics. Answer: wear and tear of assets in production (NDP = GDP minus depreciation); fall in the value of the domestic currency against foreign currencies; and as a tool of government policy through announced depreciation rates.
  • 6. The stages of growth of an economy refer to: a) the shift of population from one sector to another as industrialisation proceeds b) the rise in GDP growth rate every year c) the growth of the primary sector first d) the sequence of five-year plans. Answer: a. It is the population shift from primary to secondary and then to tertiary sector.

GNP is GDP plus primary (factor) income earned by residents from overseas, minus primary income earned by non-residents from India. Secondary income such as gifts, donations and remittances is ignored, and income from the sale of second-hand goods is also ignored. A resident is decided by how many months a person stays in a country, as defined by the OECD.

The current account records the flow of goods, services, income and transfers with the rest of the world. Its parts are the Balance of Trade (net exports minus imports of goods, a surplus or deficit), net services (tourism, banking, transport, IT and royalties), net primary income (earnings on foreign investment minus payments to foreign investors), and net current transfers (unilateral transfers such as foreign aid, remittances and gifts).

The World Bank projected a 20 per cent drop in remittances for countries like India, and even more for sub-Saharan Africa, during the COVID-19 crisis. Many prominent people urged the IMF to make an SDR allocation of up to $1 trillion to help countries, but some IMF shareholders, especially the United States which has a controlling vote, raised concerns, and India also opposed it.

Net International Investment Position (NIIP) is the value of overseas assets owned by a nation minus the value of domestic assets owned by foreigners.

  • A positive NIIP means the nation is a creditor nation (lender).
  • A negative NIIP means the nation is a debtor nation (borrower).
  • The USA has the highest NIIP; India stood 8th in 2018.
  • A resident is decided by how many months a person stays in a given country, as defined by the OECD.
  • Secondary income such as gifts, donations and remittances is ignored in GNP, and income from the sale of second-hand goods is also ignored.
  • The current account records the flow of goods, services, income and transfers with the rest of the world.
  • Its parts are the Balance of Trade (net exports minus imports of goods, a surplus or deficit), net services (tourism, banking, transport, IT and royalties), net primary income (earnings on foreign investment minus payments to foreign investors), and net current transfers (unilateral transfers such as foreign aid, remittances and gifts).
  • During the COVID-19 crisis the World Bank projected a 20 per cent drop in remittances for countries like India, and an even bigger drop for sub-Saharan Africa.
  • Many prominent people urged the IMF to make an SDR allocation of up to $1 trillion to help countries, but some IMF shareholders, especially the United States which has a controlling vote, raised concerns, and India also opposed it.
  • Net International Investment Position (NIIP) is the value of overseas assets owned by a nation minus the value of domestic assets owned by foreigners.
  • A positive NIIP means the nation is a creditor nation (lender); a negative NIIP means it is a debtor nation (borrower).
  • The USA has the highest NIIP; India stood 8th in 2018.

1.4National Income Concepts and Accounting

GNP and Income from Abroad

The normal formula is GNP = GDP + Income from Abroad. But for India it becomes GNP = GDP + (– Income from Abroad), that is, GDP – Income from Abroad. This means India's GNP is always lower than its GDP.

The uses of the GNP concept are:

  • It is the 'national income' by which the IMF ranks nations in terms of volumes at purchasing power parity (PPP). India is ranked the 3rd largest economy (after China and the USA). At the nominal or prevailing exchange rate of the rupee, India is the 7th largest economy (IMF, April 2016). Now such comparisons are also done using GDP.
  • It is a more exhaustive concept of national income than GDP. It shows the quantitative and qualitative aspects of the economy, that is, its internal and external strength.
  • It tells us about the production behaviour and pattern of an economy: how much the outside world depends on its product and how much it depends on the world (shown by the size and net flow of its balance of trade); the standard of its human resource in international terms (shown by the size and net flow of private remittances); and its position on financial support from and to world economies (shown by the net flow of interests on external lending and borrowing).
  • GNP at market prices = GDP + net factor income from abroad.
  • The IMF ranks nations by national income at purchasing power parity (PPP). PPP exchange rates are worked out by comparing the prices of the same basket of goods and services in different countries.
  • In terms of PPP dollars, India is the sixth largest economy in the world (a newer ranking than the 3rd place given earlier).

Latest: In PPP dollar terms India is the sixth largest economy in the world.

NNP

Net National Product (NNP) is GNP after deducting the loss due to depreciation. The formula is: NNP = GNP – Depreciation, or NNP = GDP + Income from Abroad – Depreciation.

The uses of NNP are:

  • It is the 'National Income' (NI) of an economy. GDP, NDP and GNP are all national income, but they are not written with capitalised 'N' and 'I'.
  • It is the purest form of the income of a nation.
  • Dividing NNP by total population gives the per capita income (PCI), that is, income per head per year. This is where the rates of depreciation followed by different nations make a difference. Higher depreciation rates mean lower PCI, whatever the reason, logical or artificial (as when depreciation is used as a tool of policymaking). Economies are free to fix any rate of depreciation for different assets, but these rates matter when the NI of nations is compared by international financial institutions like the IMF, WB and ADB.

The base year together with the methodology for calculating the National Accounts was revised by the Central Statistics Office (CSO) in January 2015.

  • National product at factor cost = National product at market prices minus indirect taxes plus subsidies.
  • Per capita income = NNP divided by the population of India.
YearPopulation (crore)Per capita income at current pricesPer capita income at constant prices (base 2011)
2016129Rs. 1,04,659Rs. 82,931
2020–21135.5above Rs. 1,28,000above Rs. 86,000
2021–22136.9above Rs. 1.50 lakhabove Rs. 93,000
2022–23138.3above Rs. 1.70 lakhabove Rs. 98,000
  • Depreciation is the wear and tear of capital assets that happens whenever something is produced. It does not become part of anybody's income, so it is subtracted from GNP.
  • NNP at market price = GNP minus depreciation.
  • NNP at factor cost = NNP at market price minus indirect taxes plus subsidies. This NNP at factor cost is the National Income of India.
  • Personal income has a very contrived formula and is not important.
  • Personal disposable income = personal income minus personal tax payments (such as income tax) minus non-tax payments (such as fines).
  • Personal income has a very contrived formula and is not important.
  • Personal disposable income = personal income minus personal tax payments (such as income tax) minus non-tax payments (such as fines).
Key Facts: Personal Disposable Income
  • It equals personal income minus direct taxes paid by households minus miscellaneous fees, fines and similar non-tax payments.
  • It is not the same as private income minus corporate savings and corporation tax, nor total household expenditure minus income tax and gifts.

Cost and Price of National Income

While calculating national income, issues of cost and price must be decided. There are two sets of costs and two sets of prices, and an economy must choose which to use.

(i) Cost: The income of an economy, that is, the value of its total produced goods and services, may be calculated at either factor cost or market cost. Factor cost is the input cost the producer incurs in producing something (cost of capital, that is, interest on loans, raw materials, labour, rent, power, etc.). It is also called factory price or production cost/price, and is the price of the commodity from the producer's side. Market cost is derived after adding indirect taxes to the factor cost. It means the cost at which goods reach the market, that is, showrooms. These indirect taxes are cenvat/central excise and CST, paid by producers to the central government in India. This is also known as the ex-factory price. The weight of state taxes is then added to it to finally derive the market cost. In general, they are called factor price and market price.

India officially used to calculate its national income at factor cost, though data at market cost was also released and used for other purposes by governments, commerce and industry. Since January 2015, the CSO has switched to calculating it at market price (market cost). Market price is calculated by adding product taxes (generally taken as the indirect taxes of the Centre and the States) to factor cost. This way India switched to the popular international practice. Once GST is implemented, it will be easier for India to calculate its national income at market price.

(ii) Price: Income can be derived at two prices, constant and current. The difference between constant and current prices is only the impact of inflation. In constant price, inflation is considered standstill at a year of the past (this past year is the base year). In current price, present-day inflation is added. Current price is basically the maximum retail price (MRP) printed on goods sold in the market.

As per new guidelines, India's base year was revised from 2004–05 to 2011–12 (January 2015). India calculates its national income at constant prices, as do other developing economies, while developed nations calculate it at current prices. For statistical purposes, the CSO also releases national income data at current prices. Why? Inflation has been a challenging aspect of policymaking in India because of its level (the range in which it moves) and stability (how stable it has been). In such situations, growth in the income levels of the population living below the poverty line (BPL) can never be measured accurately (higher inflation will show higher income), and the government can never measure the real impact of its poverty alleviation programmes.

Income of a person has three forms. The first is nominal income (the wage someone gets in hand per day or per month). The second is real income (nominal income minus the present-day rate of inflation, adjusted in percentage form). The last is disposable income (the net part of wage one is free to use, derived after deducting direct taxes from real or nominal income, depending on the need of data). In practice, while nominal income might have increased by only 5 per cent, it looks like 15 per cent if inflation is at 10 per cent. Unlike India, among developed nations inflation has been around 2 per cent for many decades (lower levels and stable too). This is why the difference between incomes at constant and current prices among them is narrow, and they calculate their national income at current prices. They get more reliable and realistic data of their income.

Trap
  • GNP = GDP + Income from Abroad normally, but for India it is GDP – Income from Abroad, so India's GNP is lower than its GDP.
  • Factor cost is the producer's input cost; market cost is factor cost plus indirect taxes. Ex-factory price is not the same as market price; state taxes are added later to reach market cost.
  • Constant price uses a past base year with no present inflation; current price includes present-day inflation and is basically the MRP.
  • Developed nations calculate national income at current prices, developing nations like India at constant prices.

Nominal GDP reflects changes in both production and price levels. A rise in prices (inflation) can raise nominal GDP even when output does not rise. Real GDP is the value of final goods and services measured at constant prices of a base year; it removes the effect of inflation or deflation and shows the actual growth in production. India uses real GDP with base year 2011–12 to measure economic growth.

In India, GDP is calculated and released by the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI). India mainly reports GDP at market prices, which includes indirect taxes (like GST) and excludes subsidies. Economic growth is measured by real GDP, that is, GDP at constant market prices.

GDP can be calculated by three methods: the production method, the expenditure method and the income method. GDP can be expressed as nominal GDP, real GDP, GDP per capita or GDP at purchasing power parity (PPP).

  • GDP per capita = total GDP divided by population. A high per capita GDP often shows prosperity but may also come from a small population or abundant resources.
  • Accelerated growth may signal overheating, leading central banks to raise interest rates; negative growth signals recession, often prompting rate cuts or stimulus.
  • GDP at PPP adjusts for differences in local prices and living expenses, so real output, income and living standards can be compared across countries without the effect of exchange rate changes.
  • GDP has limitations: it ignores environmental degradation, inequality and overall well-being.

The 8 per cent growth rate of the Indian economy in 2015–16 was based on GDP at constant prices (constant market prices).

  • GVA gives a picture of the economy from the producers' or supply side. GDP gives a picture from the consumers' or demand side, because GDP includes the effect of indirect taxes and subsidies.
  • From 2018, the RBI decided to use GDP instead of GVA for economic analysis.

Taxes and National Income

While calculating national income, direct and indirect taxes collected by the government must be considered. For direct taxes in India (individual income tax, corporate income tax, dividend tax, interest tax, etc.), there is no need for adjustment whether national income is accounted at factor cost or market cost. This is because at both costs they are the same; besides, these taxes are collected at the income source of the concerned person or group.

But indirect taxes (cenvat, customs, central sales tax, sales tax/VAT, state excise, etc.) must be taken into account if national income is accounted at factor cost (as in India). If national income is calculated at factor cost, the corpus of total indirect taxes must be deducted from it. This is because indirect taxes have been added twice: once at the point of the people or groups who pay these taxes from their disposable income while purchasing things from the market, and again at the point of the governments (as their income receipts). The collection source of indirect taxes is disposable income (what individuals and companies have after paying direct taxes, from which they purchase, and finally the indirect taxes reach the government). Thus, if national income is calculated at factor cost, the formula is:

National Income at Factor Cost = NNP at Market Cost – Indirect Taxes

However, if national income is derived at market cost, indirect taxes do not need to be deducted. In this case, the government does not have to add its income from indirect taxes to national income. This means the confusion in national income accounting at factor cost is only related to indirect taxes.

Subsidies and National Income

Like indirect taxes, the various subsidies given by governments must be adjusted while calculating national income. They are added to national income at market cost in India. Subsidies are added to national income at market cost to derive national income at factor cost. This is because the price at which subsidised goods and services are made available by the government is not their real factor cost (subsidies are given on the factor costs of goods and services); otherwise we get a distorted value (less than its real value). Thus, the formula is:

National Income at Factor Cost = NNP at Market Cost + Subsidies

If national income is derived at market cost and governments give no subsidies, there is no need for adjustment for subsidies. But there is not a single economy in the world today which does not give subsidies in one form or another.

Putting indirect taxes and subsidies together, India's National Income is derived with the following formula (as India does it at factor cost):

National Income at Factor Cost = NNP at Market Cost – Indirect Taxes + Subsidies

Key Facts: Recall
  • National Income at Factor Cost = NNP at Market Cost – Indirect Taxes + Subsidies.
  • Direct taxes need no adjustment at factor cost or market cost; only indirect taxes and subsidies need adjustment.
  • Indirect taxes are deducted because they are counted twice: in disposable income spending and as government receipts.

Revision in the Base Year and Method of National Income Accounting

The Central Statistics Office (CSO) in January 2015 released new and revised National Accounts data with two changes:

  • The base year was revised from 2004–05 to 2011–12, as recommended by the National Statistical Commission (NSC), which advised revising the base year of all economic indices every five years.
  • The methodology of calculating National Accounts was revised in line with the System of National Accounts (SNA)-2008, an internationally accepted standard.

The major changes in this revision are:

(i) The headline growth rate is now measured by GDP at constant market prices, referred to as 'GDP' (as is international practice). Earlier, growth was measured by the growth rate of GDP at factor cost and constant prices.

(ii) Sector-wise estimates of Gross Value Added (GVA) are now given at basic prices instead of factor cost. GVA measures the difference between the value of the final good and the cost of ingredients used in its production. It widens the scope of capturing more economic activity than the earlier factor cost approach (a sum of the total cost of all factors used to produce a good or service, net of taxes and subsidies). The relationships are:

  • GVA at basic prices = CE + OS/MI + CFC + production taxes less production subsidies.
  • GVA at factor cost = GVA at basic prices – production taxes less production subsidies.
  • GDP = GVA at basic prices + product taxes – product subsidies.

Here CE is compensation of employees; OS is operating surplus; MI is mixed income; and CFC is consumption of fixed capital (depreciation). Production taxes or production subsidies are paid or received in relation to production and are independent of the volume of actual production. Examples of production taxes are land revenues, stamps and registration fees and tax on profession. Examples of production subsidies are subsidies to Railways, input subsidies to farmers, subsidies to village and small industries, and administrative subsidies to corporations or cooperatives. Product taxes or subsidies are paid or received per unit of the product. Examples of product taxes are excise tax, sales tax, service tax and import and export duties. Product subsidies include food, petroleum and fertilizer subsidies, interest subsidies given to farmers and households through banks, and subsidies for providing insurance to households at lower rates.

The basic price is the amount receivable by the producer from the purchaser for a unit of a good or service produced as output, minus any tax payable (such as sales tax or VAT the buyer pays) and plus any subsidy receivable on that unit as a consequence of its production or sale. It excludes any transport charges invoiced separately by the producer. In other words, the basic price is what the seller collects for the sale, as opposed to what the buyer pays.

(iii) Comprehensive coverage of the corporate sector in manufacturing and services by incorporating annual accounts of companies filed with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) under its e-governance initiative, MCA21. Use of the MCA21 database for manufacturing companies has helped account for activities other than manufacturing undertaken by these companies.

(iv) Comprehensive coverage of the financial sector by including information from the accounts of stock brokers, stock exchanges, asset management companies, mutual funds and pension funds, and regulatory bodies including the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA) and Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA).

(v) Improved coverage of activities of local bodies and autonomous institutions, covering around 60 per cent of the grants/transfers provided to these institutions.

Important Event: CSO Base Year Revision (January 2015)
  • The CSO revised the base year from 2004–05 to 2011–12 and changed the methodology to SNA-2008.
  • Headline growth is now measured by GDP at constant market prices; GVA is given at basic prices.
  • Corporate coverage improved through MCA21; financial sector coverage widened to SEBI, PFRDA and IRDA.
  • It shifted India to international practice, making comparison easier.

India aligned its national accounts with the United Nations System of National Accounts (SNA) 2008 to ensure consistency, comparability and uniformity in national income computation across countries. This makes Indian data more reliable for international investors and economic bodies, keeps India in line with global best practices, gives integrated and consistent macroeconomic accounts, raises the credibility of estimates and supports better policy decisions through improved data quality.

Before 2015, India used GVA at factor cost, which excluded all taxes and subsidies. After the revision, GVA at basic prices became the primary measure, making the data more reflective of production realities. The base year also changed from 2004–05 to 2011–12.

AspectGVA at Basic PricesGVA at Factor Cost
Production taxesIncludes themExcludes them
Production subsidiesIncludes all subsidiesNone
What it reflectsOutput valued at actual producer pricesOutput valued without taxes/subsidies
Used todayYesNo

The National Statistical Office (NSO) computes GVA at both quarterly and annual intervals. For clarity, the Indian economy is divided into eight major sectors, and each sector's performance helps show growth patterns and identify areas needing policy intervention.

GVA = Output value – Intermediate consumption. It can also be written as GVA = GDP – Taxes on products + Subsidies on products, and GDP = GVA + (Taxes on products – Subsidies on products). GVA is the supply-side measure in national accounts and a key entry on the income side of the country's economic balance sheet.

Data source / metricBefore 2015After 2015
Manufacturing dataIndex of Industrial Production (IIP) and Annual Survey of Industries (ASI), about 2 lakh factoriesMCA21 annual accounts of about 5 lakh companies
GDP metricGDP at factor costGDP at market price; GVA at basic price for sectoral estimates
Subsidies/taxesProduct subsidies and taxes excludedProduct subsidies and taxes included
Labour incomeAll labour inputs treated equally'Effective labour input' with weights for owner, professional and helper
Key Facts: GVA to GDP in steps
  • GVA at basic prices plus indirect taxes minus subsidies = GVA plus net taxes = GDP at current market prices.
  • Adjusting current prices for inflation against the base year gives constant prices.
  • Data collection and classification follow the System of National Accounts 2008 (SNA 2008) of the United Nations Statistical Commission (UNSC).
  • The Standing Committee on Statistics (SCoS) advises on the subject, results and methodology of all surveys. It was renamed from SCES in 2023, its chairman is Pronab Sen, and it was dissolved in 2024.
  • The Collection of Statistics Act, 2008 regulates the collection of statistics on social, economic, demographic, scientific and environmental aspects by central, state and local governments. It provides penalties for companies, individuals and households that do not give information or give false information to data collectors.
  • The P. C. Mahalanobis National Award for outstanding work in statistics is given by MoSPI. P. C. Mahalanobis is called the Father of Indian Statistics and was the architect of the Second Five Year Plan. In 2020 the award went to C. Rangarajan (a former RBI governor), who was the first person to win it.
  • HSN (Harmonized System of Nomenclature), developed by the World Customs Organization (WCO), classifies goods for GST rates. SAC (Service Accounting Code) classifies services for GST rates. Example: coaching services carry SAC code 999293 at 18 per cent GST; jarda scented tobacco carries HSN code 24039930 at 28 per cent GST. This coding helps computerised accounting, billing, digitisation, surveillance and big data analytics by tax authorities.
  • PAN (Permanent Account Number) is issued by the Income Tax Department. GSTIN (Goods and Services Tax Identification Number) is issued by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC).
  • The production method of calculating GDP is also called the Gross Value Added (GVA) method.
  • GVA shows the real value created in the economy and captures the pure productive contribution of the supply side, rather than expenditure or taxes.

Income Estimates for 2017–18

Major data estimates for India's national income for 2017–18 (Economic Survey 2017–18, Vol. 2) are:

IndicatorEstimateGrowth/Comparison
GDP at constant market pricesRs. 129.85 lakh crore6.5 per cent growth (down from 7.1 per cent in 2016–17)
GVA at constant basic pricesRs. 118.71 lakh crore6.1 per cent growth (down from 6.6 per cent in 2016–17)
Per Capita Income at current pricesRs. 1,11,782About 6.1 per cent higher than 2016–17 (Rs. 1,03,219)
Chapter Summary
  • GNP = GDP + Income from Abroad normally; for India it is GDP – Income from Abroad, so GNP is lower than GDP.
  • GNP is used by the IMF for PPP rankings (India 3rd largest) and by nominal exchange rate (India 7th largest, IMF April 2016).
  • NNP = GNP – Depreciation; it is the National Income and the purest form of a nation's income; NNP divided by population gives per capita income.
  • Higher depreciation rates lower PCI and affect international comparisons by IMF, WB and ADB.
  • Factor cost is the producer's input cost; market cost adds indirect taxes; ex-factory price is factor cost plus central indirect taxes, and market cost adds state taxes too.
  • India used factor cost earlier and switched to market price in January 2015; base year changed from 2004–05 to 2011–12.
  • Constant price uses a past base year without present inflation; current price includes present inflation and is basically MRP.
  • India and other developing economies use constant prices; developed nations use current prices because their inflation is low and stable (around 2 per cent).
  • National Income at Factor Cost = NNP at Market Cost – Indirect Taxes + Subsidies.
  • Direct taxes need no adjustment; indirect taxes are deducted at factor cost because they are counted twice.
  • CSO's January 2015 revision followed NSC advice (base year every five years) and SNA-2008; growth is now GDP at constant market prices and GVA at basic prices.
  • For 2017–18, GDP at constant market prices was Rs. 129.85 lakh crore (6.5 per cent growth), GVA at basic prices Rs. 118.71 lakh crore (6.1 per cent), and PCI at current prices Rs. 1,11,782.
Practice Questions
  • 1. For India, GNP is calculated as: (a) GDP + Income from Abroad (b) GDP – Income from Abroad (c) GDP + Depreciation (d) GDP – Subsidies. Answer: b. India's income from abroad is negative, so GNP = GDP – Income from Abroad.
  • 2. Which statement about the January 2015 CSO revision is correct? (a) Base year changed from 2011–12 to 2004–05 (b) Growth is now measured by GDP at factor cost (c) GVA is now given at basic prices (d) SNA-1993 was adopted. Answer: c. The base year changed from 2004–05 to 2011–12, growth is measured by GDP at constant market prices, and SNA-2008 was adopted.
  • 3. Assertion (A): Indirect taxes are deducted when national income is calculated at factor cost. Reason (R): Indirect taxes are counted twice, once in disposable income spending and again as government receipts. (a) Both A and R are true and R explains A (b) Both true but R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true. Answer: a. The double counting is exactly why deduction is needed.
  • 4. Which of the following is a production tax? (a) Excise duty (b) Sales tax (c) Land revenue (d) Customs duty. Answer: c. Land revenue, stamps and registration fees and tax on profession are production taxes; the others are product taxes.
  • 5. Per capita income for 2017–18 at current prices was estimated at: (a) Rs. 1,03,219 (b) Rs. 1,11,782 (c) Rs. 129.85 lakh crore (d) Rs. 118.71 lakh crore. Answer: b. Rs. 1,03,219 was the 2016–17 figure; the other two are GDP and GVA totals.
  • 6. Short answer: Why do developed nations calculate national income at current prices? Answer: Their inflation has been low and stable (around 2 per cent) for decades, so the gap between constant and current price incomes is narrow and current price data is more reliable and realistic.

GDP growth averaged 7.5 per cent between 2014–15 and 2016–17, among the best in the world. It was expected to fall to 6.5 per cent in 2017–18, bringing the four-year average to 7.3 per cent. This was about 3 percentage points above the global average of the last three years and nearly 4 percentage points above the average of emerging market and developing economies.

Indicator2014–152015–162016–172017–18
GDP at constant market prices (Rs. crore)1,05,36,9841,13,81,0021,21,89,854 (PE)1,29,85,363 (AE)
GDP growth rate (%)7.58.07.16.5
GVA at constant basic prices (Rs. crore)97,19,0231,04,90,5141,11,85,440 (PE)1,18,71,321 (AE)
GVA growth rate (%)7.27.96.66.1
Gross savings (% of GDP)33.132.3nana
Gross capital formation (% of GDP)34.433.3nana
  • In 2017–18, GVA growth of 6.1 per cent (against 6.6 per cent in 2016–17) came from lower growth in agriculture and allied activities (2.1 per cent) and industry (4.4 per cent).
  • Services were expected to grow at 8.3 per cent in 2017–18, against 7.7 per cent in 2016–17. Within services, only public administration, defence and other services was expected to decline.
  • GDP growth rose from a low of 5.5 per cent in 2012–13 for three years and peaked in 2015–16, with Q4 printing 9.1 per cent (GVA growth also peaked in Q4 of 2015–16). Growth began slowing from Q1 of 2016–17.

Quarter-wise real growth (per cent):

Sector2016-17 Q1Q2Q3Q42017-18 Q1Q2
GVA at basic prices7.66.86.75.65.66.1
Agriculture and allied2.54.16.95.22.31.7
Industry7.45.96.23.11.65.8
of which Manufacturing10.77.78.25.31.27.0
Services9.07.86.97.28.77.1
GDP at market prices7.97.57.06.15.76.3

The second half of 2017–18 was worked out using the First Advance Estimate and quarterly data up to Q2 of 2017–18.

  • GDP growth averaged 7.5 per cent between 2014–15 and 2016–17, among the best in the world. It was expected to fall to 6.5 per cent in 2017–18, bringing the four-year average to 7.3 per cent. This was about 3 percentage points above the global average of the last three years and nearly 4 percentage points above the average of emerging market and developing economies.
  • In 2017–18, GVA growth of 6.1 per cent (against 6.6 per cent in 2016–17) came from lower growth in agriculture and allied activities (2.1 per cent) and industry (4.4 per cent).
  • Services were expected to grow at 8.3 per cent in 2017–18, against 7.7 per cent in 2016–17. Within services, only public administration, defence and other services was expected to decline.
  • GDP growth rose from a low of 5.5 per cent in 2012–13 for three years and peaked in 2015–16, with Q4 printing 9.1 per cent (GVA growth also peaked in Q4 of 2015–16). Growth began slowing from Q1 of 2016–17.
  • The second half of 2017–18 was worked out using the First Advance Estimate and quarterly data up to Q2 of 2017–18.
Indicator2014–152015–162016–172017–18
GDP at constant market prices (Rs. crore)1,05,36,9841,13,81,0021,21,89,854 (PE)1,29,85,363 (AE)
GDP growth rate (%)7.58.07.16.5
GVA at constant basic prices (Rs. crore)97,19,0231,04,90,5141,11,85,440 (PE)1,18,71,321 (AE)
GVA growth rate (%)7.27.96.66.1
Gross savings (% of GDP)33.132.3nana
Gross capital formation (% of GDP)34.433.3nana
Sector2016-17 Q1Q2Q3Q42017-18 Q1Q2
GVA at basic prices7.66.86.75.65.66.1
Agriculture and allied2.54.16.95.22.31.7
Industry7.45.96.23.11.65.8
of which Manufacturing10.77.78.25.31.27.0
Services9.07.86.97.28.77.1
GDP at market prices7.97.57.06.15.76.3

Newer GDP growth figures are now given on a new base year of 2022 (real or constant market prices).

YearOld series (base 2011)New series (base 2022)
FY256.5%7.1%
FY267.4%7.6%
FY276.8–7.2% (Economic Survey 2026, Jan 2026)7.0–7.4% (revised by the CEA in Feb 2026)

Latest: GDP growth for FY25 is 7.1% and for FY26 is 7.6% on the new base year 2022 (older series: 6.5% and 7.4% on base 2011).